The SEC's Chaos Kept Alabama's Playoff Door Open. Texas A&M Is the One Team That Can Shut It.
A league with no dominant team is projected to send two or more three-loss teams to the playoff, but a third straight loss to a 1-3 SEC opponent would read differently from the first two.

Alabama is still a playoff team. Not because it has earned the benefit of the doubt with its last two games, but because the rest of the SEC has spent October making sure nobody in the league gets to look down on a two-loss team.
That is the good news for the Crimson Tide heading into Saturday. The bad news is that the margin it buys runs out at exactly one more loss, and the next opponent is the team on the schedule that Alabama can least afford to lose to.
Texas A&M arrives at 4-3 and 1-3 in the SEC. Lose to Georgia and Tennessee and you are a good team in a hard league. Lose to Georgia, Tennessee and the Aggies and you are a team in a slide, and the selection committee is not in the business of rewarding slides.
The League Has No Untouchables
Start with how strange the last Saturday was. Auburn beat No. 1 Georgia 27-24 in Athens. Florida beat Texas 27-24 in Austin. Tennessee beat Alabama 26-10. When the AP poll came out Oct. 18, Georgia had fallen from No. 1 to No. 5, Texas from No. 7 to No. 19 and Alabama from No. 6 to No. 13.
Bill Bender of The Sporting News framed the day bluntly, and he was right to.
Blame the SEC schedule if you want, but it's not an excuse for any of these teams.Bill Bender, via The Sporting News
He is correct that the schedule is not an excuse. It is, however, a cushion. Brad Crawford's CBS Sports projection published that same night put five SEC teams in the 12-team field and made a forecast that should comfort every fan base south of the Ohio River: for the first time in the playoff era, he expects at least two three-loss SEC teams to get in.
If the committee is going to take three-loss SEC teams, a 5-2 Alabama with its two losses to a top-five Georgia and a top-15 Tennessee is not in trouble. It is in the middle of the pack, which in this league is still the bracket.
Where Alabama Sits Now
The drop is real, though. On Oct. 13, after the Georgia loss, John Talty's CBS Sports projection had Alabama as the No. 5 seed, noting the 20-17 loss included some disputed calls. Five days later, after Knoxville, Crawford's version had the Tide as the No. 9 seed, playing a first-round game at UCLA with a quarterfinal against Miami waiting in the Peach Bowl.
That is a fall of four seed lines in one week, and the difference between hosting a first-round game in Tuscaloosa and flying west in December.
Alabama by the Numbers
- Record
- 5‑2 (3‑2 SEC)
- AP rank, Oct. 11
- No. 6
- AP rank, Oct. 18
- No. 13
- CBS projected seed, Oct. 13
- No. 5
- CBS projected seed, Oct. 18
- No. 9
The conference title race is a different matter, and Alabama should stop pretending otherwise. Georgia and Kentucky are 4-1 in the league. Tennessee and Ole Miss are 3-1. Alabama has already lost to Georgia and Tennessee, which means any tie it ends up in near the top is likely to break against it. As Crawford put it, good luck sorting out the tiebreaker for who plays Georgia in Atlanta. For Alabama, the realistic route to January is an at-large bid, not a championship game.
Why Saturday Is Different
Here is the uncomfortable part. Alabama's playoff case is built almost entirely on the company it keeps. Its losses came to good teams. Its remaining schedule offers one chance to add a quality win.
That chance is in Baton Rouge. Crawford wrote that the Tigers are the only ranked team left on Alabama's schedule and that the Nov. 7 game at LSU could decide one of the last spots in the field. LSU is No. 18 at 5-2. After that come Vanderbilt on the road, Chattanooga at home and an Iron Bowl against an Auburn team that just beat Georgia and is receiving votes in the AP poll.
None of that works if Alabama loses Saturday. A third straight loss, to a team picked No. 8 in the preseason AP poll but now 1-3 in the league, would leave Alabama at 5-3, needing to win in Baton Rouge and everywhere else just to reach 9-3, while carrying a loss the committee would treat as damaging. The Aggies have scored six points in each of their last two SEC losses, to LSU and Missouri. Losing to that offense is not the kind of defeat a résumé absorbs.
The Rest of Saturday Matters Too
Alabama should also be watching the night game. No. 7 Ole Miss plays at No. 19 Texas at 6:30 p.m. Central on ABC, and an Ole Miss win pushes the Rebels to 4-1 in the league. Every loss by a team around Alabama in the standings makes the room in the bracket a little wider. No. 11 Tennessee goes to South Carolina, and No. 12 Kentucky hosts Vanderbilt.
The SEC's parity cuts both ways. It is why Alabama can survive two losses. It is also why there will be no sympathy for a third. The league is going to produce plenty of 9-3 and 10-2 teams with arguments, and the committee will separate them on who they lost to.
My view: Alabama is a playoff team if it beats Texas A&M and wins in Baton Rouge on Nov. 7. It is on the outside if it loses either one. Saturday afternoon is the cheaper of those two tests, and it should be treated like the more urgent one.
After Saturday comes the open date, then LSU. The bracket math will look very different depending on what Alabama brings into that week.
Follow us on FacebookEvery new Alabama story, in your feedSources: CBS Sports, bowl projections after Week 7 upsets (Oct. 18); CBS Sports, CFP bracket projection (Oct. 13); NCAA.com, AP Top 25 for Oct. 18; The Sporting News via Yahoo Sports, SEC Hangover Saturday; BamaCentral (SI), what to know about the Aggies; The Crimson Sideline, Ole Miss at Texas headlines SEC Saturday

