Is Lane Kiffin Built for the Big Job? LSU's 6-3 Start Has Reopened an Old Question.
Kiffin has been fired by the Raiders and USC and has thrived where expectations were lower. Three losses into a $91 million contract at LSU, the question is no longer whether he can coach. It is whether he can carry a blue blood's weight.

Baton Rouge, La. Lane Kiffin stood at a podium in Tiger Stadium on Saturday night, three losses into his first season at LSU, and was asked what keeps his team from making the plays that win games.
"I don't know," he said, according to ESPN. "We had a chance."
It was an honest answer. It was also the kind of answer that reopens a question that has followed Kiffin for nearly two decades: Is he built for the biggest jobs in the sport, the ones where every loss is a referendum?
The Case Against
Start with the résumé, because the pattern is hard to ignore.
Kiffin's two big-market jobs before LSU both ended with him being fired early. The Oakland Raiders let him go four games into his second season in 2008, with a 5-15 record and a public feud with owner Al Davis, who said, "I picked the wrong guy," according to NFL.com. USC fired him five games into the 2013 season, hours after a 62-41 loss at Arizona State, ESPN reported. He got the news at the airport on the way home and later called it the lowest point of his career, according to CBS Sports.
In between, he spent one season at Tennessee, went 7-6 and left for USC.
Now look at LSU. Kiffin signed a seven-year deal worth $91 million, about $13 million a year, according to theScore. At his introduction he said he wanted LSU to be "the number one destination for elite players in all of America," Flashscore reported. The Tigers are 6-3.
LSU's Three Losses
- Sept. 19 at No. 8 Ole Miss
- L 32‑24 (LSU was No. 7)
- Oct. 10 at Kentucky
- L 35‑34, OT (LSU was No. 10)
- Nov. 7 vs. Alabama
- L 31‑13
Saturday's loss was the most damaging, and the most Kiffin-like. LSU outgained Alabama 457-285 and scored 13 points. It went 0 for 4 on fourth down, the most failed fourth-down tries in a game without a conversion in Kiffin's career, and reached the red zone four times for one touchdown and one field goal, according to ESPN. Kiffin said he kept going for it because he did not believe field goals would be enough. That is a defensible philosophy. It is also a philosophy that has to work when the whole country is watching.
The loss at Ole Miss stung differently. It came in Kiffin's return to Oxford, against the program he left before last season's playoff, and his former defensive coordinator, Pete Golding, was on the other sideline as the Rebels' head coach.
The national reaction has been harsh. ESPN's Paul Finebaum said on his radio show Sunday that "you have to wonder if Lane Kiffin isn't just all sizzle and no substance," according to A to Z Sports. LSU's chances to make the College Football Playoff fell from 51% to 25% after the Alabama game, according to the Allstate Playoff Predictor cited by ESPN.
The Case For
Here is what the "big market" argument misses: Kiffin's problem in Oakland and Los Angeles was rarely that the moment was too big. It was conflict with the people above him, and a roster or a situation he did not fully control.
When he has had control, he has won. At Ole Miss he went 55-19 over six seasons and finished 11-1 last year, a program best that earned the Rebels their first College Football Playoff berth, according to theScore. He wanted to coach them in that playoff and was told no by athletic director Keith Carter. That is not the record of a coach who wilts under pressure. Oxford in November was never a quiet place to work.
The numbers from Saturday also cut both ways. A team that outgains Alabama by 172 yards is not broken. LSU's three losses came by eight points, one point in overtime, and a game it led 13-10 late in the third quarter. Those are execution problems, the kind that coaching can fix, not talent problems.
And it is nine games. Kiffin still has a top-10 Texas team at home on Saturday, then trips to Tennessee and Arkansas. Win two of those three and LSU finishes 8-4 or better in year one with a quarterback, Sam Leavitt, who just threw for 380 yards against Alabama.
The Verdict, For Now
Is Lane Kiffin cut out for a job like LSU? The honest answer is that he has never stayed long enough at one to prove it either way.
What his career does show is this: Kiffin has been at his best when he is the underdog building something, and at his most vulnerable when he is expected to deliver immediately and is answering to people who are already impatient. LSU is a program that won national titles in 2003, 2007 and 2019 and does not do patience well.
The next three Saturdays will not settle the question. But a home win over Texas would change the conversation in a hurry, and a third straight loss in a big game would make the old label harder to shake. In Baton Rouge, the clock is already running.
Follow us on FacebookEvery new Alabama story, in your feedSources: ESPN, Fourth-down flops doom LSU in "really disappointing" loss to Alabama; AP via KSAT, Trinidad Chambliss leads No. 8 Mississippi past No. 7 LSU 32-24 in Lane Kiffin's return to Ole Miss; AP via KSL, Kentucky QB Minchey scores 2-point conversion in overtime to beat No. 10 LSU 35-34; theScore, Report: Kiffin signs 7-year, $91M contract with LSU; Flashscore, Lane Kiffin after being hired as head coach: "LSU is the best job in football"; NFL.com, Raiders fire Kiffin four games into second season; ESPN, USC Trojans fire coach Lane Kiffin after 3-2 start, blowout loss; CBS Sports, Lane Kiffin: USC airport firing was the lowest point in my career; Saturday Down South, Lane Kiffin coaching profile; Yahoo Sports (A to Z Sports), Paul Finebaum on Lane Kiffin after LSU's loss to Alabama

