Monday, November 16, 2026Game Week: Chattanooga · Sat., Nov. 21, 1 p.m. CT, SEC Network+
Subscribe
Latest
Four-star RB Nigel Newkirk flips from Alabama to Ohio StateChattanooga at Alabama: Sat., Nov. 21, 1 p.m. CT, SEC Network+DeBoer undecided on resting Keelon Russell vs. ChattanoogaAlabama holds at No. 7 in Coaches Poll; AP poll out Monday 1 p.m. CTTennessee and Texas win, setting up a three-way chase for AtlantaCFP rankings Tuesday at 8 p.m. CT; Alabama is No. 3Four-star RB Nigel Newkirk flips from Alabama to Ohio StateChattanooga at Alabama: Sat., Nov. 21, 1 p.m. CT, SEC Network+DeBoer undecided on resting Keelon Russell vs. ChattanoogaAlabama holds at No. 7 in Coaches Poll; AP poll out Monday 1 p.m. CTTennessee and Texas win, setting up a three-way chase for AtlantaCFP rankings Tuesday at 8 p.m. CT; Alabama is No. 3
SEC

Alabama Belongs in the CFP Top Four Tonight. The Committee's Harder Job Is Tennessee.

After the win at LSU and Miami's loss to Notre Dame, the case for putting Kalen DeBoer's Alabama in a bye spot in Tuesday's second College Football Playoff rankings is strong. Ranking Tennessee eight spots behind the team it beat 26-10 is the part that needs fixing.

Alabama supporters fill the stands next to a crimson team display at Levi’s Stadium.
Alabama supporters fill the stands next to a crimson team display at Levi’s Stadium. File photo, Jan. 2019. · Photo: Legoktm, CC BY-SA 4.0

The College Football Playoff committee will put Alabama in its top four Tuesday night, and it should. What it will probably not do is fix the strangest thing about its first set of rankings, which is that Tennessee beat Alabama by 16 points and was ranked eight spots below it.

Both things can be true. Alabama has the better resume. Tennessee has a better argument than the committee gave it credit for a week ago.

The second rankings air on ESPN at about 9 p.m. ET (8 p.m. CT), in a window between the Champions Classic basketball games, according to USA Today.

Why Alabama Moves Up

Alabama was No. 5 in the first rankings on Nov. 3, at 6-2, the highest spot for any two-loss team. Then it went to Baton Rouge as an underdog and beat LSU 31-13, scoring the last 21 points.

The four teams ahead of it did not all hold. Miami, No. 1 a week ago, lost to Notre Dame. Indiana, No. 4, was idle. Georgia won 42-7 at Ole Miss. Utah stayed unbeaten.

The national projections reflect that. USA Today's Paul Myerberg projects Alabama at No. 3, behind Georgia and Utah and ahead of Notre Dame and Miami. "Winning at LSU is yet another feather in the cap for Alabama," he wrote. Bama Hammer collected similar picks: NBC's Nicole Auerbach, ESPN's Heather Dinich and USA Today's Matthew Glenesk all have Alabama third, and College Football News' Pete Futiak has it fourth.

Not everyone is there. The Sporting News' Bill Bender has Alabama sixth, and ESPN's weekly panel of 10 split between sixth and eighth, according to Bama Hammer.

The bye is the stakes. In this year's 12-team bracket, the top four seeds skip the first round whether or not they win their conference.

First CFP rankings, top 13 (Nov. 3)

RankTeamRecord then
1Miami8-0
2Georgia7-1
3Utah8-0
4Indiana8-1
5Alabama6-2
6Kentucky7-1
7Texas6-2
8UCLA8-0
9BYU7-1
10Ole Miss6-2
11Notre Dame7-1
12Ohio State6-2
13Tennessee6-2

Source: NCAA.com.

The Schedule Argument Holds Up

The best case for Alabama is not one win. It is the whole slate. Alabama has the No. 1 strength of schedule in the country by ESPN's FPI and Jeff Sagarin's ratings, according to Bama Hammer. Its two losses came to Georgia, by three points, and at Tennessee.

That is where the committee usually lands, and it is a defensible place to land. A two-loss team that has played the hardest schedule in the sport and won at LSU belongs above one-loss teams whose best wins are thinner.

The Tennessee Problem

Here is the part the committee has not squared. Tennessee beat Alabama 26-10 in Knoxville on Oct. 17. Both teams were 6-2 in the first rankings. Alabama was fifth and Tennessee was 13th.

Two teams with the same record, one of which beat the other by 16, look like teams that should be compared directly. Eight spots apart is not a close comparison. It is a statement that the result in Knoxville barely counted.

Myerberg made the same point in his projection, writing that Tennessee's win over Alabama "doesn't seem to apply" when the committee compares the two. He projects Tennessee ninth Tuesday, after its 34-6 rout of Kentucky moved the Volunteers from No. 16 to No. 9 in the AP poll.

The counterargument is real. Tennessee's schedule strength ranks 23rd by FPI, according to Bama Hammer, well behind Alabama's. The committee is allowed to say a full season outweighs one Saturday.

My position: Alabama should be third or fourth tonight, and Tennessee should be closer than five or six spots behind it. If the committee leaves a gap of six spots between them again, it should explain why a 16-point head-to-head result is worth less than a few points of schedule strength.

What It Means for the SEC

The SEC could have five teams in the top 10 tonight if Myerberg's projection holds: Georgia first, Alabama third, Texas seventh, Tennessee ninth and Kentucky 10th.

That crowding matters in December. Only so many SEC teams can get in, and the league's teams keep playing each other. Alabama's remaining schedule is Vanderbilt, Chattanooga and Auburn. Tennessee plays at Texas A&M on Saturday, and Texas goes to LSU at night.

Alabama's job is simpler than Tennessee's. Win three more and it will almost certainly stay in a bye spot. Tennessee needs the committee to change its mind, and committees do not like to do that in public.

The rankings come out tonight. Alabama plays at Vanderbilt at 11:45 a.m. CT Saturday on SEC Network.

Follow us on FacebookEvery new Alabama story, in your feed

Sources: NCAA.com, Miami, Georgia lead the first College Football Playoff rankings of 2026; USA Today via Yahoo Sports, CFP rankings prediction: Georgia is No. 1, but look who crashes the top four; Bama Hammer, Predicting where Alabama should be and will be ranked in the second Playoff rankings; USA Today via Yahoo Sports, CFP rankings show today: where to watch, time, TV channel; The Crimson Sideline, Alabama climbs to No. 7 and Georgia retakes No. 1; The Crimson Sideline, Alabama is No. 5 in the first CFP rankings

College Football PlayoffCFP RankingsAlabamaTennesseeGeorgiaKalen DeBoerTexasKentuckySECColumn

More From The Sideline

All stories