Alabama's Last Trip to Vanderbilt Ended in a 40-35 Upset. This One Asks a Different Question.
Vanderbilt beat No. 1 Alabama 40-35 as a 23.5-point underdog in 2024. Kalen DeBoer's No. 7 Tide goes back as a 19.5-point favorite against a 4-5 team with a freshman quarterback, and the history of this series says the upset was the exception.

Tuscaloosa, Ala. The last time Alabama went to Nashville, it left with the loss that still sits at the top of every list of Kalen DeBoer's worst days in Tuscaloosa. Vanderbilt 40, No. 1 Alabama 35, on Oct. 5, 2024, was not just a bad afternoon. By almost any measure the record books keep, it was one of the least likely results the SEC has produced.
Alabama goes back Saturday at 11:45 a.m. as the No. 7 team in the country and a 19.5-point favorite, according to the AP. That is a smaller number than the one it carried two years ago, against a Vanderbilt team that, on paper, is nowhere near as dangerous.
So the question this week is not whether lightning strikes twice. It is whether this Alabama team, which just closed out LSU with the game's last 21 points in Baton Rouge, can handle a game it is supposed to win without making it interesting.
How Rare 2024 Was
The numbers from that night are worth repeating, because time has a way of sanding them down.
Vanderbilt closed as a 23.5-point underdog at most sportsbooks, according to Fox Sports. It had lost 23 straight games to Alabama and had not beaten the Tide since 1984. It was 0-60 all-time against AP top-five opponents.
Alabama, meanwhile, had been 60-0 since 1978 as the AP's No. 1 team and a favorite of 20 points or more, Fox Sports found. It was only the fourth time Alabama had lost to an unranked team while ranked No. 1. The other three came against Georgia Tech in 1962, Mississippi State in 1980 and Texas A&M in 2021.
Vanderbilt's own athletic department calls it the program's first win over a No. 1-ranked opponent. Diego Pavia completed 80 percent of his passes for 252 yards and two touchdowns and ran for 56 more, according to Fox Sports.
It was the moment that made DeBoer's first season feel like a transition rather than a continuation.
The Correction
A year later, Alabama took its revenge without much drama on the scoreboard and plenty of it in the first half. No. 10 Alabama beat No. 16 Vanderbilt 30-14 on Oct. 4, 2025, in Tuscaloosa, according to Alabama Crimson Tide On SI.
It was 14-14 at halftime. Then Alabama did what it had failed to do in Nashville: it took the ball and kept it. Jam Miller ran 22 times for 136 yards, Alabama held the ball for 37:23 to Vanderbilt's 22:37, and it scored on all five of its red-zone trips while Vanderbilt turned it over twice inside the Alabama 20.
Vanderbilt still went 10-3 that season and 6-2 in the SEC, with Pavia finishing as the Heisman runner-up, according to the On SI preview. That 2024 upset turned out to be the front edge of the best two-year stretch the Commodores have had in a long time, not a fluke.
This Is a Different Vanderbilt
Pavia is gone. In his place is Jared Curtis, a freshman who arrived as a consensus five-star recruit. Curtis has thrown for 1,657 yards with eight touchdowns and eight interceptions, according to the AP.
The results have followed the youth. Vanderbilt opened 3-0, then lost five straight SEC games: at Auburn, at Georgia, and against Ole Miss, Arkansas and Kentucky, according to ESPN's schedule. The Ole Miss game ended 52-17.
The skid ended Saturday in Starkville, where Vanderbilt beat Mississippi State 25-23 for its first SEC win of the year. It was the Commodores' first win over Mississippi State since 2004, according to ESPN.
Clark Lea, now in his sixth season, liked what he saw.
"We played the way that we want to play at Vanderbilt."Clark Lea, via ESPN
That is the warning label for Saturday. Vanderbilt ran for 160 yards and piled up 20 first downs to Mississippi State's 12, ESPN reported. When the Commodores win, they do it by shortening the game and keeping the ball, which is exactly how Alabama beat them last season.
What History Actually Says
Pull back far enough and this series is not close. Alabama has dominated it for decades, and the 23-game winning streak that ended in 2024 is the clearest summary of what the normal relationship looks like.
The lesson of 2024 was not that Vanderbilt is dangerous every year. It was that Alabama, on the road, against a team with a quarterback who believed, played without urgency for 60 minutes and paid for it.
This Alabama team has given every sign it learned that. It trailed LSU in the third quarter in one of the loudest stadiums in the country and won the fourth quarter 14-0. It has moved from No. 9 to No. 7 in the AP poll, and Touchdown Alabama noted that a 10-2 regular season would give it close to an 80 percent chance at a first-round playoff bye even without a trip to Atlanta.
That math only works if Alabama wins the games it is expected to win. The 2024 team found out how quickly a season can tilt on one of those.
The Test
Saturday is an 11:45 a.m. kickoff on SEC Network at FirstBank Stadium, an early start a week after a draining night in Baton Rouge. It is the kind of setup that old coaches used to circle in red and young players tend to wave off.
The fair verdict is that Alabama should win comfortably. The honest one is that the Tide owes Nashville a cleaner performance than the last one, and that the way it wins will say as much about this team as the LSU game did.
Follow us on FacebookEvery new Alabama story, in your feedSources: Fox Sports, Contextualizing Vanderbilt's massive win vs. Alabama; Vanderbilt Athletics, Kickoff against Tide announced; Alabama Crimson Tide On SI, Upon Further Review: No. 10 Alabama 30, No. 16 Vanderbilt 14; Alabama Crimson Tide On SI, 2026 early opponent preview: Vanderbilt; AP via Crossville Chronicle, No. 7 Alabama and Vanderbilt meet in SEC play; ESPN, Vanderbilt 25-23 Mississippi State game recap; ESPN, Vanderbilt 2026 schedule; Touchdown Alabama, Where Alabama is ranked in the AP Poll after beating LSU; Touchdown Alabama, Can Alabama secure a first-round bye without making the SEC title game?


